Is Putin mad?

There has been a lot of commentary in the media suggesting that Putin is mad, some even ridiculously suggesting this had something to do with “COVID”. In this video clip (thankfully with transcript provided in this link), he answers a woman who questions whether his operations in Ukraine were necessary, and he answers her at length:

I don’t know whether what he says about the situation is true or not, I certainly do know that the Western media has lied about so many things that they can’t be trusted to give us an accurate picture of what is happening at all. The one thing I am not seeing in his response is evidence of madness, he responds calmly and tries to explain his actions. If there is any truth in these particular claims then it ought to give us some pause for thought I think:

What did these people demand? Nothing but the basic things: the right to speak their mother tongue, i.e. the Russian, and maintain their traditions and culture. These were by no means extraordinary demands. But no. These territories were put under economic blockade; disconnected from the banking system; the supplies of food were stopped; the payments of the pensions and social assistance were suspended. Sometimes, some handouts were given, but in order to get those pensions and benefits a person had to cross the separation line.

(Here he is speaking about the 8 years since 2014 I believe):

Approximately 13,000-14,000 people have been killed during these years. Over 500 children have been killed or injured. But what is particularly intolerable is that the so-called “civilized” West has preferred all these years to look the other way. All these years – 8 years! Eight years!

He says that if Ukraine joins NATO then the disputed Crimea region will be invaded:

If Ukraine is a NATO member, then according to the North Atlantic Treaty, all other members must support the country in case of a military conflict. No one besides us has recognized Crimea as a Russian territory. The yare [sic] conducting military operations in Donbas but also could move onto Crimea, and in such case we would have to fight with the whole of NATO. What is that? Do you understand the consequences? I think everyone understands.

My own belief is that Putin is not mad, I don’t know the truth about any of the claims on either side, but I see no evidence of madness here. He may be lying (then again he may not) but I don’t think he is mad.

2 Likes

What is the “yare”?

Putin’s long reply does not make any sense to me. We don’t trust our media to tell the truth with good reason, but does that mean Putin’s “facts” are more believable?

4 Likes

His claims about the casualties may be true or not, as I wrote above I don’t know, but I think it is pretty clear that his real concern in all this is that Russia will lose the Crimea again. I doubt he is really quite so concerned about the Russian speaking people there, I think it’s more a strategically important thing.

I think “they are” [correction] is a reference to Ukrainian paramilitaries or something like that, i.e. I think he is afraid of a proxy invasion of the Crimea that will lead to it becoming part of NATO with the rest of the Ukraine.

2 Likes

I don’t trust the propaganda from either or all sides (that’s about all we get), but Putins demands seem reasonable enough to me. They are at least a better deal than the alternative - entering WW3.
Ukraine isn’t important enough to the US or Europe’s interests to fight a World War over it.

2 Likes

Correction I thing “the yare” is a mistake in the translation it should say “they are” :rofl:

What I said about paramilitaries is still what I think he is referring to though.

2 Likes

There were rumors about his health, and talk about how he didn’t look healthy, nor completely with-it. Tumor?

Who really knows what Ukraine has done during its Thugocracies? But, I don’t believe anything that Putin says…excepting that he wants his legacy to be a reunited Russian Empire. That I believe.

Was Russian threatened by Ukraine? Don’t think so. Did Putin have reason to invade and begin a full scale war, including indiscriminately bombing civilian facilities? I don’t think so.

Is Putin Russian and former KGB and an acolyte of Dugin? Yes. Does that make him Mad? Probably.

2 Likes

No doubt Putin looks at the Crimea strategically. All territory owned by an autocrat is strategically important. Holding an empire is the strategic goal.
And, indeed, that does not make him “mad”, but nor does it legitimize his re-conquest and re-subjugation of populations by force of arms, or the empire itself - no matter where its borders. There is as much reason to deny Putin his empire now as there was to deny Hitler his Reich. If America or the “free” nations of Europe - whether under NATO flags or their own - don’t have the stomach to confront Putin militarily, let it not be on the excuse that Putin has valid strategic reasons, grounded in history, race, religion or morality to own the territories and populations he extorts, subjugates and terrorizes. No autocrat is entitled to an empire, even if it is called a “sphere of influence”.

4 Likes